Most recent comments
Moldejazz 2018
Camilla, 3 months, 3 weeks
Romjulen 2018
Camilla, 10 months, 3 weeks
Liveblogg nyttårsaften 2017
Tor, 1 year, 10 months
Jogging og blogging
Are, 2 years, 10 months
Liveblogg nyttårsaften 2016
Are, 2 years, 10 months
Reading in dark times
Are, 3 years
Moldejazz 2016
Camilla, 3 years, 3 months
Dørskilt
Karoline, 3 years, 4 months
Melody Gardot
Camilla, 4 months, 1 week
Den årlige påske-kommentaren
Tor, 7 months, 1 week
50 book challenge
Camilla, 10 months, 3 weeks
Controls
Register

Anti-cuts study-in, v.2

Being a politically aware person all round, and a great fan (at least in theory) of telling off people who have done something wrong, not to mention feeling terribly betrayed by the LibDems despite my lack of voting power in Britain (they seemed like the sensible people, dammit; and now they are all skulking around doing dodgy things with dodgy people -- it is not right) I naturally joined the local protest against cuts in education funding in Britain. It helped that I am very much opposed to the idea that education should be something you have to pay for in principle.


I joined up with some people from the department (although I must say there was a shocking lack of lecturers, and I only saw one of my students) and headed over to Bristo Square (which is just off George Square) to be shouted at through a megaphone. I must say, the megaphone-shouting of the day was very disappointing. I don't think I heard more than two sentences together throughout the day.

We quickly headed off, however, armed with copies of Nick Clegg's pledge to vote against cuts. Here is a picture of him holding it (I don't know who has taken it, and no websites hosting it seem to feel that that is relevant information):



The piece of paper says the following:

I pledge...
TO VOTE AGAINST
ANY INCREASE IN FEES
in the next parliament
and to pressure the
government to introduce
A FAIRER ALTERNATIVE

And it is signed by Nick Clegg, the deceptively friendly-looking man holding it.

Now, you may say (as Rebekah repeatedly has) that all politicians lie and that anyone naïve enough to believe them deserve what is coming to them. But that is not quite true. Politicians fudge their replies, dodge questions, prevaricate and generally behave in a thoroughly unsatisfactory way, yes. But they rarely provide u-turns like this one. Here is Clegg before the election. Here is an excerpt from a satirical article I found:

“I guess what I meant to sign was an agreement to get rid of students over a six year period. I think all those students misunderstood my real message. You cannot blame me or my party for saying anything to try and get in to power.”

Looking rather worried he also added, ” We quite honestly would have sold Vince Cable’s arse on Clapham Common if it meant I could get my foot across the Downing Street threshold.” Mr Clegg confirmed whilst taking a quick drag on his cigarette before setting alight to other election pledges in his office dustbin.

But back to the demonstration. I think the idea was that we would post the copies of the pledge through the letterbox of the LibDem offices in Edinburgh. This meant walking from Bristo Square to Haymarket, which we did quite cheerfully. We were cold, but at this point not dreadfully so. There were a couple of nifty chants, the most popular being

No ifs,
No buts,
No education cuts!

and

Nick Clegg,
Shame on you!
Shame on you
for turning blue!

I seem to remember there being one about him having turned Tory, but it never caught on and now I cannot remember. Having reached Haymarket, this is what faced us:


They did not seem quite as cheery, and they did seem quite reluctant to let us anywhere near the letterbox.

And so the study-in began. It was like a sit-in, but with books. And outside. They kept interrupting it with appeals that we couldn't hear because lecturers insisted on confirming their notorious ineptitude in all things technical by speaking softly into megaphones while holding them like michrophones. But what mattered was the principle of the thing.


(Yes, that sign says "This shit wouldn't happen at Hogwarts")


Once the people trying to talk at us stopped doing that, however, I had thought we would settle in for a proper evening of study-ining. I had only had time for a fleeting thought in the direction of how I should have brought a thermos with some tea, however, when everyone suddenly got on their feet again. There was then some commotion as the pledge copies were handed over and two representatives were allowed to put them through the letterbox to great cheers. And then the whole demonstration moved back towards Bristo Square.

I was a little surprised, because there had been talk about sitting there "all day" and we had hardly had time to even open our books without some interruption or other. But I assumed everyone was feeling the cold. At the very first intersection, however, everyone sat down again.

Now, at this point I started thinking thoughts.
I do that sometimes.

The proportion of students to generally scary-looking people with masks around their necks (ready to be put on at any moment, and sometimes already worn) seemed to change. And the cries also changed towards something along the lines of

students, workers, unite and fight.

It annoyed me a little that instead of making a point outside the LibDem offices, we were suddenly (as one of my co-students put it) reclaiming the streets. By sitting down at every intersection. And with the increasing aggression around me joining up with my slight annoyance, I decided that sitting down at every intersection between Haymarket and Bristo Square was not worth the potential of getting caught up in a hijacked demonstration like the one in London.

If we were going to be sitting down in the street, the sensible thing to do would seem to be to do that where we could make a clear point. I don't know why we didn't. Whether it was because someone felt a bunch of people studying in the streets was not aggressive enough, or whether the organisers simply got cold and felt they had to walk a little in between. At any rate, I went home after Tollcross.

Versions:

Version 1

Camilla, 24.11.10 16:51

Version 2

Camilla, 27.11.10 01:34

Version 3

Camilla, 28.11.10 21:34